Debate Over James Blair Middle School Name Change

Community voices unite in a discussion about the school's name change.

News Summary

In Williamsburg, a discussion is gaining momentum regarding the potential renaming of James Blair Middle School due to its association with a historical figure involved in slavery. A recent survey revealed mixed opinions from the community, with a slight majority opposing the name change. School board members are weighing public sentiment and considering educational efforts to provide historical context. As the conversation evolves, the board aims to discuss alternative name suggestions at an upcoming meeting, while also reviewing the financial implications of a name change.

Debate Heats Up Over School Name Change in Williamsburg

In the charming city of Williamsburg, a lively discussion is underway about the future name of James Blair Middle School. With a history that includes its namesake being a minister and slaveowner, the school board is wrestling with whether the name is still appropriate in today’s world. The conversation has been ignited by a dedicated group known as the Campaign for Honorable and Inclusive School Names, which feels that a name change is overdue.

Community Weighs In

To gauge public sentiment, a comprehensive four-day community survey was launched, drawing in responses from 1,724 individuals. This group included a variety of voices, such as 409 students, 29 staff members, 148 parents/guardians, and 923 members of the general public. The survey results revealed a surprisingly divided opinion: 53% opposed changing the school’s name, while only 37% showed support for the move, leaving a small 10% undecided.

What the Numbers Say

Breaking down the feedback further, current students of James Blair were largely against the renaming, with 192 voting against and only 124 in favor. Among school staff, there was a modest participation rate of 44%, with 14 against and 11 for the change. A more significant proportion of parents and guardians chimed in too, with 93 opposing the name change and 33 supporting it.

The general public also had their say with 498 against renaming and 398 in favor. Community members were vocal on their positions, with many identifying as local residents. The survey’s feedback illustrates the complex feelings around the school’s name and its historical implications.

The School Board’s Take

After reviewing the data, the school board’s 15-member committee conducted an anonymous poll. Curiously, 11 members favored renaming, while just one chose to abstain. Board member Michael Hosang noted that across all groups surveyed, opposition to renaming was evident, pointing out the importance of listening to community desires.

Education Before Decision?

Meanwhile, some board members felt that the public may not fully grasp the historical context surrounding James Blair. They pondered whether spreading awareness about the past might influence opinions before any decisions are made.

Rich History Behind the School

It’s worth noting that James Blair Middle School has a long history, initially established in 1955 as a segregated high school. It didn’t transition to a junior high until 1973. With this rich tapestry, many feel that a name carries significant weight in representing both values and history.

Looking Ahead

An expression of disappointment came from board member Andrea Donnor, who believed that the community should recognize the inappropriateness of honoring someone tied to slavery. Concerns were further raised with a student’s comment in the survey that seemed to trivialize the implications of slavery, comparing it to pet ownership—a thought that understandably troubled some board members.

As the conversations continue, the school board plans to delve into alternative name suggestions during their meeting on May 6. Currently, they’ve expressed a preference for names that do not honor specific individuals, which may help avoid similar controversies in the future.

Cost of Change

The financial impact of a name change is also under scrutiny, with estimates suggesting the cost will be around $92,334.50. Astoundingly, this represents only 0.05% of the fiscal year 2025 budget—a small price tag for a potentially significant shift.

What’s Next?

Community feedback remains at the forefront of this discussion, with the school board’s committee set to present its findings and potential name suggestions at the upcoming meeting on April 16 at 6:30 p.m.. As this conversation develops, it’s clear that the name of James Blair Middle School is about much more than just a title—it’s a reflection of values, history, and the diverse perspectives of the community.